纠纷的解决与程序公正——兼论程序法治视野中的实体公正

将纠纷解决所要追求的公正划分为实体公正与程序公正,这是大部分学者长期以来的习惯认识。但在程序法治的视野中,就纠纷的解决来说,应当认识到,通过公正的纠纷解决程序所产生的结果理应被视为是公正的,强调实体公正实在无任何益处可言,因此有必要抛弃实体公正的说法,集中资源构建程序公正。

A Discussion on Dispute Settlement and Procedural Justice with Cross-reference to Substantial Justice from the Perspective of Procedural Constitutionality

The fairness pursued in dispute settlement is conventionally divided into substantial justice and procedural justice by scholars in many countries.However,from the perspective of procedural constitutionality,a settlement reached through procedural justice should be deemed as fair,and thus there is no point in emphasizing the substantial justice.Instead,it is more sensible to centralize resources to construct the procedural justice.