Testing equality of proportions with incomplete correlated data

Let (ψ_i,φ_i) be independent, identically distributed pairs of zero-one random variables with (possible) dependence of ψ_i and φ_i within the pair. For n pairs, both variables are observed, but for m₁ additional pairs only ψ_i is observed and for m₂ others φ_i is observed. If π_1· = P{ψ_i = 1} and π_·1=P{φ_i, the problem is to test π_1·=π_·1. Maximum likelihood estimates of π_1· and π_·1 are obtained via the EM algorithm. A test statistic is developed whose null distribution is asymptotically chi-square with one degree of freedom (as n and either m₁ or m₂ tend to infinity). If m₁ = m₂ = 0 the statistic reduces to that of McNemar's test; if n = 0, it is equivalent to the statistic for testing equality of two independent proportions. This test is compared with other tests by means of Pitman efficiency. Examples are presented.