是达到了最高学术水平,还是罕见的假冒伪劣--评荆贵生主编的《古代汉语》

河南师范大学教授荆贵生宣称由他主编的<古代汉语>达到了最高学术水平,本文则以大量无可辩驳的事实揭露该书是一部罕见的假冒伪劣之作.此外,作者谴责了庸俗的书评,并对如何制止践踏学术道德、违背学术规范的不良现象,提出了自己的看法.

Reaching the Highest Academic Level, or Being a Rare Product of Imitations and Low Quality--Comments on the Textbook of Ancient Chinese Chiefly Edited by Prof. Jing Guisheng

Prof. Jing Gui-sheng of Henan Normal University declared that the textbook of Ancient Chinese chiefly edited by himself has reached the highest academic level. This article,by means of a large number of indisputable facts,exposed the textbook just as a rare textbook of imitations and low quality. Besides,the authors condemned the vulgar book reviews,and advanced our own views about checking the disgusting conducts of treading on academic morality and deviating from academic standards.