“超女”潮起潮落到“快女”与常青树“美国偶像”对比背后的深层次思考

2005年超级女生登上它的顶峰,2009年改头换面的快乐女生没有出现主办方期待的卷土重来,而通常被认为超级女声、快乐女生模板的美国偶像却一如既往的延续着辉煌。通过多角度、多形式较为全面的分析比较了超女、快女与美国偶像的主要差异,在此基础上分析比较了超女、快女与美国偶像外部社会结构情境的差异,并从三个方面对差异背后的深层次问题进行了思考。

Reflections on the Comparison of Super Girls Rise and Fall into Happy Girls with the Evergreen American Idol

Super Girls climbed to its peak in 2005.In 2009 disguised Happy Girls did not make a comeback which organizers expected.However,American Idol,generally considered the template of Super Girls and Happy Girls has continued its glory as always.In this paper,the author makes a comprehensive analysis of the major differences between Super Girls,Happy Girls and American Idol.Then,based on that,she makes a further comparison between their external social structures and situations,and reflects on the deep-rooted is...