医疗事故技术鉴定制度的立法缺陷及其完善

医疗事故鉴定是医患纠纷处理的重要证据,对医患双方的利益都至关重要。现行医疗事故鉴定制度关于鉴定的提起规定由医患双方共同委托,但由于医患双方很难取得一致意见,而使得鉴定变得十分困难;同时卫生行政部门对医疗争议进行医疗事故的判定,通过对初次鉴定的审查以决定是否进一步鉴定的规定,有明显的行政权干涉民事权的倾向;医疗事故鉴定结论作为医学依据同样应当受到司法审查,而医学会的鉴定行为缘其关乎医患双方的切身利益,同样应当受到相应的监督。建议最高人民法院就有关问题尽早作出司法解释。

The Regulating Drawback and Its Alteration of the Medical Malpractice Identification System

The report of medical malpractice identification (MMI), important evidence for resolving the medical dispute, is of great importance to both doctors and patients. The regulation on the way of MMI application makes MMI extremely difficult; the regulation that the health department decides the result of the first identification report makes the civil right violated by the administration; as the medical basis of medical malpractice resolving, MMI is of great significance to the right of both doctors and patients, and therefore should be strictly examined and supervised.