Deficiencies of minimum discrepancy estimators

Suppose the multinomial parameters p_r (θ) are functions of a real valued parameter 0, r = 1,2, …, k. A minimum discrepancy (m.d.) estimator θ of θ is defined as one which minimises the discrepancy function D = Σ n_rf(p_r/n_r), for a suitable function f where n_r is the relative frequency in r-th cell, r = 1,2, …, k. All the usual estimators like maximum likelihood (m. l), minimum chi-square (m. c. s.)., etc. are m.d. estimators. All m.d. estimators have the same asymptotic (first order) efficiency. They are compared on the basis of their deficiencies, a concept recently introduced by Hodges and Lehmann 2]. The expression for least deficiency at any θ is derived. It is shown that in general uniformly least deficient estimators do not exist. Necessary and sufficient conditions on p_r (0) for m. t. and m. c. s. estimators to be uniformly least deficient are obtained.