Comparison of two measures of association in two-way contingency tables

Stuart's (1953) measure of association in contingency tables, t_C, based on Kendall's (1962) t, is compared with Goodman and Kruskal's (1954, 1959, 1963, 1972) measure G. First, it is proved that |G| ≥ |t_C|; and then it is shown that the upper bound for the asymptotic variance of G is not necessarily always smaller than the upper bound for the asymptotic variance of t_C. It is proved, however, that the upper bound for the coefficient of variation of G cannot be larger in absolute value than the upper bound for the coefficient of variation of t_C. The asymptotic variance of t_C is also derived and hence we obtain an upper bound for this asymptotic variance which is sharper than Stuart's (1953) upper bound.