文学作品内容与形式的辩证矛盾是不存在的——兼与童庆炳教授商榷

童庆炳教授内容形式关系论的重要论文《论文学作品内容与形式的辩证矛盾》存在着严重不足,体现在四个方面。一是他对内容、形式、题材概念的界定,二是他认为文学作品内容、形式概念的存在具有合理性,三是形式与题材的关系,四是以"对立原理"作为理论依据。文学作品的内容和形式根本上是整一的,形式征服题材的情况是不存在的,文学作品内容与形式的辩证矛盾是不存在的。

The Dialectic Contradiction between Content and Form Never Appears A discussion with Prof. Tong Qingbing

This thesis analyzed the deficiencies of Prof. Tong Qingbing’s paper---"The Dialectic Contradiction between Content and Form of Literal Works" from four parts: the delimitation of content,form and subject matter; his argument for the rationality of the existence of the concepts of content and form; the relation between subject matter and form; "the contradictory principle"as a theoretical basis. This thesis holds that the content and form in literature are basically unitary; the situation that the form conquers the subject matter,or even the dialectic contradiction in literal works between content and form does not exist.