我们究竟需要什么样的文学批评——对《十美女作家批判书》的批评

中国当代一些被称为美女作家的,其创作思想和作品存在这样或那样的问题,对她们进行批评是完全必要的。但是,《十美女作家批判书》的作者对这些所谓美女作家和她们的作品的批判少有对作品和作品中的人物形象的具体分析,大都是翻来覆去、不厌其烦的讽刺、谩骂、侮辱甚至人身攻击,以及颠来倒去的武断的断语,完全背离了文学批评的真谛。文学批评应该回到文学批评的本原上来,真正正常而健康地发展。

What Literary Criticism Do We Need: A Criticism of Animadvert of Ten Beauty Writers

There exist some problems of this kind or that in the thoughts and works of the so-called beauty writers in present China. The criticism of them is necessary. However, the writer of Animadvert of Ten Beauty Writers seldom offers concrete analysis of their works and the characters in their works. What the author does is the repeated and boring ridicule, curse, assault, and even personal assault, and repeated arbitrary statements. This practice is completely against the true meaning of literary criticism. Literary criticism should turn to its root, developing normally and healthily.